Friday, December 7, 2012

How Google can fix Google TV

There is still a lot of potential in the TV / content space. Some facts / observations:


  1. People in the US watch between 5-6 hours of TV a day (Yes, people really watch that much TV on average)
  2. More than 80% of people watch content on their TV that is not their ideal choice because finding their ideal choice is too hard
  3. Choices on the TV screen have exploded because now you not only have traditional TV but over the top content such as Netflix, Youtube, Hulu, apps and  other websites that offer HD content. This means there is more complexity than ever before
  4. This is a problem that is eminently solvable through technology. Recommendation engines are a solved problem at this point as long as there is enough user data to seed them. There are several companies that have the data including Google, Apple and increasingly Amazon
  5. There are a lot of incentives to solve the problem. e.g. TV advertising is huge and there is a lot of scope for technology to make advertising on TV a lot more targeted and effective

Four top things Google needs to fix w.r.t. Google TV:

  1. Fix the usability of the software. Some of the most used experiences on Google TV such as Youtube and Chrome which are owned by Google and fully in their control still suck. They need to create a consistent and usable design framework which other developers can emulate. Taking a page out of Apple's playbook here wouldn't be the worst thing
  2. Push the envelope on what's possible. Google is an outstanding technology company which has a strong presence in mobile. Why can't it create an amazing experience that leverages a smartphone with a TV screen e.g. a game platform which uses the TV screen as a shared screen and the smartphone as a private screen or controller?
  3. Proliferate the ecosystem. Think about the increased potential of the platform if it was to become cheaper than Roku and still provide people with a cloud based DVR. This is how Android has kept up in the smartphone wars
  4. An honest conversation within the company on how serious it is about Google TV. Having a great answer will help them in their conversations with partners, both content providers as well as device manufacturers. Google TV should not feel like a Google hobby to its partners

There are several challenges for Google, a few of which are below:

  1. Content creators have not yet figured out how to get their offerings directly in front of consumers and get consumers to pay for them. The Hulu experiment doesn't seem to have worked. If content creators are not careful they run the risk of being pushed into change, much like music companies. There is a recognition of this, but the reality is that they are still paid by the cable / satellite companies. Getting them on board will be a key element of the solution to this space
  2. Google is not yet a truly consumer centric company. There is not enough focus on details and the usability of almost all of their experiences lags behind competitors such as Apple as a result. Google needs to address silos within the company and empower other groups such as UX in addition to engineering
  3. As a company Google has taken on a lot. Search. Email. Office productivity tools. Social. Smartphones. Video. Operating systems. Cloud storage and processing. Its a challenge to put the right amount of attention on Google TV while dominating / maintaining dominance in all of the other areas

Google also has some major advantages:

  1. An outstanding engineering team and one of the best collections of talent overall on the planet
  2. An internal culture which fosters experimentation, creativity and entrepreneurship. It is because of this culture that Google TV even exists
  3. Great assets to build on, including Android, Youtube, Search and Chrome

Bottom line: Google has had a 3 year lead in the TV space with Google TV. They need to have a sense of urgency otherwise the window will close on them. There are others who are working on this opportunity as well. Expect strong network effects when someone cracks this space which will not only be restricted to TV but extend to other domains such as video and smartphones


I originally posted this on quora as a reply to a question on what Google needs to do to make Google TV succesful. Reposting here as relevant to products