Universal remotes. Google TV. iPhones/iPods/iPads. We've always had a fascination with devices that enable multiple uses. Some of them have been great ideas, e.g. the iPhone. Some of them not so great, e.g. the TV VCR combo.
We're arguably closer to the convergence dream than at any time in the past, with the creation and wide adoption of smartphones and tablets. With these comes processing power, installable apps and interfaces to allow a wide variety of use cases.
So does this mean that we can finally get rid of everything else? After all, if there is a use case, there is an "app" for that, right? Well, its not quite that easy. Lets illustrate using a popular use case, the use of a smartphone as a remote:
The basic idea is that you create an app that can mimic the buttons of a remote and an IR blaster is attached to your smartphone (Voomote/Redeye) or kept on a tabletop (peel) or inside your AV stack (Harmony Link/Griffin Beacon) to blast IR at your devices
There are several problems:
Interface constraints: The buttons on a regular remote have tactile feel which helps build muscle memory over time. This means you don't have to look at the remote and can access its functions passively rather than actively. Not true for the most part with a smartphone screen. Since it has limited or no tactile feel it needs to be looked at so that you are pushing the right buttons
Dedicated function: A TV remote is built for doing one function really well - switch on your TV and control the devices in your stack. A smartphone is built for a variety of functions, including making phone calls. This means that the physical buttons and overall form factor of the smartphone is not quite right for using as a remote. It is designed to make calls or switch between apps. Also, while a TV remote is always available for being used to control the TV, a smartphone might leave the house or be occupied by someone making a call or using an app
Context switching: When you pick up the remote, it already knows you want it to control devices. When you pick up the smartphone, it does not know what you want it to do. Do you want to make a phone call? Do you want to play angry birds? Or do you want to use it as a remote? In order to get it to work as a remote, you have to unlock the screen (because communication devices need to be protected from unauthorised access), launch the right app (because it is designed to allow you to use multiple apps) and then tell the app what state your system is in (since a smartphone can be in use, out of the house or inaccessible, you likely used other remotes to change the state of your A/V stack). This can be a lot of additional effort
So what does this mean? Is convergence a mirage that is never going to be real? That extreme is not true either. What this means is that convergence will open up new possibilities and open our minds to changing what we are used to in terms of user experience. The iPhone wasn't the best way to make a phone call and suffered the same tactile limitations pointed out above when compared to a feature phone. While other phone makers had spent years getting the cost down and increasing battery life, the iPhone was a high cost and low battery life product. But it overcame those limitations based on additional use cases it uncovered. Visual voicemail totally transformed how we access voicemail, which was till then a pretty sucky experience. A much much better way to access the internet. Great open apps ecosystem. And yes, iTunes.
A lot of us valued these additional features and switched to using iPhones. The net benefit of the additional features was greater than the net loss of the things it did not have. And while a lot of us prefer the iPhone and the iClones, there is still a segment that prefers the lower cost, tactile feel, better battery life and lower complexity of a phone that does not do much more than make phone calls
Going back to our example of using the smartphone as a remote. There are many disadvantages, some of which I cover above. But there are also things the traditional remotes simply can't do because they don't have two way communication, a screen or an internet connection. e.g. the Peel app or the Harmony Link app will eventually become a lot better at solving the discovery problem - i.e. which program to watch. They will be a lot more visual in presenting content to consumers. Apps like Miso will enable us to marry social connectivity with TV watching. Will these provide enough net benefit to consumers so they can look past their shortcomings? It hasn't happened yet and time alone will tell if that will change. What I know for sure is that they will cause existing experiences to evolve as well.
But don't be surprised if your traditional remote is still around. It'll evolve, but most likely still be alive because there are limits to convergence
We're arguably closer to the convergence dream than at any time in the past, with the creation and wide adoption of smartphones and tablets. With these comes processing power, installable apps and interfaces to allow a wide variety of use cases.
So does this mean that we can finally get rid of everything else? After all, if there is a use case, there is an "app" for that, right? Well, its not quite that easy. Lets illustrate using a popular use case, the use of a smartphone as a remote:
The basic idea is that you create an app that can mimic the buttons of a remote and an IR blaster is attached to your smartphone (Voomote/Redeye) or kept on a tabletop (peel) or inside your AV stack (Harmony Link/Griffin Beacon) to blast IR at your devices
There are several problems:
Interface constraints: The buttons on a regular remote have tactile feel which helps build muscle memory over time. This means you don't have to look at the remote and can access its functions passively rather than actively. Not true for the most part with a smartphone screen. Since it has limited or no tactile feel it needs to be looked at so that you are pushing the right buttons
Dedicated function: A TV remote is built for doing one function really well - switch on your TV and control the devices in your stack. A smartphone is built for a variety of functions, including making phone calls. This means that the physical buttons and overall form factor of the smartphone is not quite right for using as a remote. It is designed to make calls or switch between apps. Also, while a TV remote is always available for being used to control the TV, a smartphone might leave the house or be occupied by someone making a call or using an app
Context switching: When you pick up the remote, it already knows you want it to control devices. When you pick up the smartphone, it does not know what you want it to do. Do you want to make a phone call? Do you want to play angry birds? Or do you want to use it as a remote? In order to get it to work as a remote, you have to unlock the screen (because communication devices need to be protected from unauthorised access), launch the right app (because it is designed to allow you to use multiple apps) and then tell the app what state your system is in (since a smartphone can be in use, out of the house or inaccessible, you likely used other remotes to change the state of your A/V stack). This can be a lot of additional effort
So what does this mean? Is convergence a mirage that is never going to be real? That extreme is not true either. What this means is that convergence will open up new possibilities and open our minds to changing what we are used to in terms of user experience. The iPhone wasn't the best way to make a phone call and suffered the same tactile limitations pointed out above when compared to a feature phone. While other phone makers had spent years getting the cost down and increasing battery life, the iPhone was a high cost and low battery life product. But it overcame those limitations based on additional use cases it uncovered. Visual voicemail totally transformed how we access voicemail, which was till then a pretty sucky experience. A much much better way to access the internet. Great open apps ecosystem. And yes, iTunes.
A lot of us valued these additional features and switched to using iPhones. The net benefit of the additional features was greater than the net loss of the things it did not have. And while a lot of us prefer the iPhone and the iClones, there is still a segment that prefers the lower cost, tactile feel, better battery life and lower complexity of a phone that does not do much more than make phone calls
Going back to our example of using the smartphone as a remote. There are many disadvantages, some of which I cover above. But there are also things the traditional remotes simply can't do because they don't have two way communication, a screen or an internet connection. e.g. the Peel app or the Harmony Link app will eventually become a lot better at solving the discovery problem - i.e. which program to watch. They will be a lot more visual in presenting content to consumers. Apps like Miso will enable us to marry social connectivity with TV watching. Will these provide enough net benefit to consumers so they can look past their shortcomings? It hasn't happened yet and time alone will tell if that will change. What I know for sure is that they will cause existing experiences to evolve as well.
But don't be surprised if your traditional remote is still around. It'll evolve, but most likely still be alive because there are limits to convergence
I read your post and I found it amazing .Your thought process is wonderful. The way you express yourself is awesome.
ReplyDeleteDecision Making Process
Thanks for the kind words. Glad you enjoyed it
Delete